The Educator's Two Jobs
Educators face AI from two sides: using it well in their own work, and helping learners build their own fluency. See how the four competencies apply to each.
Two Jobs, One Framework
Most professionals only need to use AI well themselves. Educators have a second job: their learners are using AI too, often without much guidance, and they look to their teachers for how to do it well. That gives you two roles:
- Fluent practitioner. You use AI to plan, create materials, give feedback, and handle administrative work, while protecting your students and your own professional judgment.
- Fluency teacher. You help learners decide when AI helps their learning and when it gets in the way, describe what they need, judge what they get back, and be honest about how they used it.
The two roles reinforce each other. Students learn far more from watching how you actually use AI, including the times you decide not to, than from any policy statement.
The 4D AI Fluency Framework gives both jobs a shared vocabulary:
- 1 Delegation
What should AI do in my teaching, and in my students' learning?
- 2 Description
How do I, and my students, ask for what's needed?
- 3 Discernment
Is this material accurate, appropriate, and at the right level?
- 4 Diligence
Am I protecting students, being transparent, and owning the result?
| Competency | As a fluent practitioner | As a fluency teacher |
|---|---|---|
| Delegation | Hand off prep and admin; keep relationships and judgment of student work. | Help students tell apart AI use that supports learning from use that replaces it. |
| Description | Describe lessons, levels, and needs precisely enough to get usable materials. | Teach students to describe what they need, including asking AI to coach rather than answer. |
| Discernment | Check materials for accuracy, bias, reading level, and fit with your curriculum. | Build habits of verifying, questioning, and comparing AI output. |
| Diligence | Protect student data, follow policy, disclose AI use where it matters. | Set clear expectations and teach honest disclosure. |
Why “Ban It” and “Allow Everything” Both Fail
Early responses to generative AI often swung between two extremes:
- Ban it. Students still use AI, just without guidance and without telling you. The students who follow the rule fall behind in a skill their future workplaces expect.
- Allow everything. Students outsource the very thinking assignments were designed to build, and many don’t notice it happening.
Fluency is the middle path: deliberate, assignment-by-assignment decisions about AI’s role, made visible to students and explained in terms of what they’re meant to learn.
Common mistake: running a session on “how to use [specific AI tool]” and calling it AI literacy.
Tools change every few months. The questions behind them don’t: Should I use AI for this? How do I ask for what I need? Is this right? Am I being honest about how it was made? Teach those questions, using whatever tool is handy as the example.
- Draw two columns: My teaching work and My students’ learning.
- In the first column, list five recurring tasks in your work (for example, writing quiz questions, emailing families, adapting readings, giving feedback, writing recommendation letters).
- In the second column, list five things your students do where AI is likely already showing up (for example, essays, problem sets, research, studying for tests, group projects).
- For each item in both columns, write one word: Helps, Risky, or Depends.
- Circle the “Depends” items. Most of this course is about making those calls well.
1. What are the educator's 'two jobs' with AI?
Educators are both practitioners who use AI and teachers who shape how learners use it. Each role strengthens the other.
2. Why does a blanket AI ban tend to fail?
A ban mostly pushes AI use out of sight. Deliberate, assignment-level decisions, explained to students, work better.
3. Which is the best example of teaching AI fluency rather than a tool?
Delegation decisions transfer to any tool. Menu tours go out of date in months.
About the Framework
The 4D AI Fluency Framework was created by Rick Dakan and Joseph Feller with Anthropic, and is released under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. This course’s lessons, examples, and activities are original. New to the framework? Start with AI Fluency: Foundations.
Up Next
Before using AI in your own teaching, you need to decide what to hand off and what to keep, starting with your students’ privacy.