Core Values in an Academic Culture
Module 1 · Why Baldrige in Higher Education

Core Values in an Academic Culture

The eleven Baldrige core values translated into the daily life of a school of technology and computing, and honest answers to the objections faculty raise: students aren't customers, academic freedom, shared governance, and 'this is corporate.'

Why Start With Values

The Criteria questions only make sense once you understand the beliefs behind them. Baldrige calls these the core values and concepts. They’re the behaviors found in high-performing organizations, and every Criteria question can be traced back to one or more of them.

There are eleven. In the Education edition, the third reads student-focused excellence:

  1. Systems perspective
  2. Visionary leadership
  3. Student-focused excellence (customer-focused excellence in other sectors)
  4. Valuing people
  5. Agility and resilience
  6. Organizational learning
  7. Focus on success and innovation
  8. Management by fact
  9. Societal contributions
  10. Ethics and transparency
  11. Delivering value and results

One Way to Group Them

Eleven values are hard to remember. Grouping them by the question each answers makes them easier to discuss with faculty. The grouping below is a teaching device, not part of the official framework.

How we think• Systems perspective• Organizational learning• Management by factSee the whole school; learn from evidence.How we lead• Visionary leadership• Ethics and transparency• Societal contributionsSet direction others can trust.Whom we serve• Student-focused excellence• Valuing peopleStudents, faculty, staff, and partners.How we perform• Agility and resilience• Focus on success and innovation• Delivering value and resultsAdapt fast; deliver outcomes that matter.A teaching grouping, not part of the official framework.

What Each Value Looks Like at STC

Core valueAt Northbridge’s School of Technology and Computing, it looks like…
Systems perspectiveSeeing that a change to the intro programming course affects data structures, the capstone, advising load, and retention.
Visionary leadershipThe dean sets a clear direction (“every graduate can build responsibly with AI”) and models it.
Student-focused excellenceDesigning schedules, support, and assessments around working adults who study at night across time zones.
Valuing peopleTreating practitioner adjunct faculty as colleagues: onboarding, a voice in curriculum, development, and recognition.
Agility and resilienceUpdating a cloud course in one quarter when a provider retires a service, not waiting for a two-year review cycle.
Organizational learningTurning each quarter’s course data and faculty debriefs into changes for the next quarter.
Focus on success and innovationRunning small pilots, like AI tutoring in one section, and scaling what works.
Management by factDeciding where to add tutoring based on DFW rates (D, F, and withdrawal) by course and student group, not on anecdotes.
Societal contributionsFree cyber-hygiene workshops for local nonprofits; building a diverse regional tech workforce.
Ethics and transparencyPublishing outcomes honestly, protecting student data, and having clear rules on academic integrity and AI use.
Delivering value and resultsGraduates who get and keep good jobs, at a cost and time that make sense for working adults.

Answering the Objections

Faculty will push back, and they should. Have honest answers ready.

“Students aren’t customers.” Agreed, they aren’t only customers. They’re also learners and partners in their own education. The Education Criteria say “students and other customers” on purpose. Being student-focused doesn’t mean giving students whatever they ask for. It means understanding what they need to succeed, including rigor, and designing for it. Employers, transfer partners, and the community are customers too.

A student plays three roles at once, and a student-focused school designs for all of them:

LearnerRigor, challenge,honest feedbackCustomerAccess, service,value for moneyPartnerCo-owns goals,shapes the schoolThestudentBeing student-focused means serving all three roles, not just the customer one.

“This threatens academic freedom.” Baldrige never prescribes what to teach or research. It asks how the school decides on curriculum, how it knows students are learning, and how it improves. Faculty keep authority over content, and Baldrige makes their decisions visible and evidence-based.

“We have shared governance; we can’t ‘manage’ like a company.” Category 1 asks about your leadership and governance system, whatever it is. Shared governance is a structure Baldrige expects you to describe and use well, for example in how the faculty council reviews program changes.

“This is corporate jargon.” Some terms are. Translate them into your own language (“work processes” becomes “how we design and deliver courses”). The questions are what matter, not the words.

⚠️ Common Pitfall: Values on the Wall, Not in the Work

Common mistake: a school puts “student-centered” in its values statement. Meanwhile, advising is only available 9 to 5 Pacific time, for a student body that mostly works days and partly lives in other time zones.

Examiners look for values in how work is done, not in statements. For each value you claim, ask: Which process shows this, and what result proves it? If you can’t answer, the value is aspirational, which is fine, but say so.


Key Takeaway

The eleven core values are the beliefs behind every Criteria question. In the Education edition, the customer value becomes student-focused excellence. Translate each value into concrete behaviors in your school, and treat faculty objections as useful: Baldrige asks how and how do you know, never what to teach. A value only counts when you can point to a process that shows it and a result that proves it.

🧪 Try It: Run a Values Evidence Check

With two or three colleagues, pick three core values your school says it holds. For each, fill in:

ValueA process that shows itA result that proves itGap?

Example for STC: Student-focused excellence → evening and weekend virtual advising → advising satisfaction 4.4/5 for online students, up from 3.6 → no gap.

Any row you can’t complete is a candidate improvement project.

🧠 Knowledge Check

1. In the Education edition, which core value corresponds to 'customer-focused excellence' in other sectors?

2. A faculty member says Baldrige threatens academic freedom. What's the best response?

3. Deciding where to add tutoring based on DFW rates by course and student group is an example of which core value?

4. How do examiners judge whether a school really holds a value?