The Organizational Situation (P.2)
Finish the Organizational Profile: STC's competitive position, the changes reshaping computing education, where to find comparative data in higher ed and its limits, strategic challenges and advantages, and the performance improvement system that ties course, program, and school cycles together.
What P.2 Asks
P.1 described who you are. P.2 Organizational Situation describes what you’re up against and how you get better. It has three parts:
- P.2a Competitive environment: your position, the changes affecting it, and your sources of comparative data
- P.2b Strategic context: your key strategic challenges, threats, advantages, and opportunities
- P.2c Performance improvement system: your overall approach to improving, and the tools you use
P.2a Competitive Environment
(1) Competitive position
STC enrolls about 1,400 students (60% undergraduate). Within the Puget Sound market for adult-serving computing degrees, it estimates its share at about 8%. Undergraduate enrollment is flat over three years. Graduate enrollment grew quickly but swings with international demand.
Its competitors fall into four groups:
| Competitor type | What they offer | How STC differentiates |
|---|---|---|
| National online universities | Low cost, self-paced, huge marketing budgets | Live practitioner faculty; local employer network |
| Regional public universities (online and evening programs) | Brand, lower in-state tuition | Four starts a year; transfer-friendly; adult-focused support |
| Community college applied bachelor’s degrees | Very low cost, local | Graduate pathway; cloud and security depth |
| Bootcamps and vendor certifications | Short, cheap, job-focused | Accredited degree; broader foundations; certifications built into courses |
A simple positioning map makes the differentiation visible:
(2) Changes affecting the competitive situation
- Generative AI is changing entry-level software and IT work, and with it what employers expect from new graduates.
- International graduate demand moves with visa policy, which makes graduate enrollment volatile.
- Short-term credentials are growing, and some employers now hire on skills rather than degrees.
- Opportunities for collaboration: employer-sponsored cohorts, and stackable certificates that count toward the degree.
(3) Comparative data sources
Baldrige asks where you get comparisons, inside and outside education, and what limits them. This question trips up many schools.
| Source | What it gives you | Limitation |
|---|---|---|
| IPEDS (federal) | Retention, graduation, Outcome Measures for part-time and transfer students, completions by field | Institution-level, not school-level; slow (one to two years old) |
| National Student Clearinghouse Research Center | Persistence, transfer, and completion across institutions | Aggregate benchmarks; institution-specific data requires participation |
| College Scorecard | Earnings and debt by field of study | Only students who received federal aid; earnings lag several years |
| NSSE or an adult-student survey such as RNL’s Adult Student Priorities Survey | Engagement and satisfaction benchmarks against peer groups | Survey cost; response rates for online adults can be low |
| CUPA-HR | Faculty and staff salary benchmarks | Few benchmarks for adjunct pay by discipline |
| Labor-market data (e.g., job-posting analytics) | Skill demand and wages by occupation | Shows demand, not graduate outcomes |
| Outside education | Customer-service and Net Promoter benchmarks; cybersecurity maturity benchmarks | Must be translated to a school context |
P.2b Strategic Context
| Key items for STC | |
|---|---|
| Strategic challenges and threats | 1. Keeping curriculum current as AI changes entry-level work · 2. Retaining online working adults through their first year · 3. Volatile international graduate enrollment · 4. Adjunct engagement and consistency across ~110 instructors · 5. Price pressure from national online providers |
| Strategic advantages | 1. Practitioner faculty with current industry practice · 2. Four start dates and evening delivery · 3. A 14-employer advisory board and internship network |
| Strategic opportunities | 1. Employer-sponsored cohorts · 2. Certificates that stack into degrees · 3. AI-assisted tutoring and feedback at scale |
These lists matter later. In Category 2, examiners will check whether your strategic objectives address these challenges and use these advantages. If a challenge has no matching objective, that’s a gap.
P.2c Performance Improvement System
Most schools have improvement activities but no system. STC links three cycles that run at different speeds, so what’s learned in one feeds the next.
The quarterly course cycle uses PDSA (Plan-Do-Study-Act):
- 1 Plan
Pick one change from last quarter's data (e.g., add a lab walkthrough video)
- 2 Do
Run it in all sections from the master shell
- 3 Study
Compare DFW rate, lab completion, and feedback to the prior quarter
- 4 Act
Keep, adjust, or drop; update the master shell
Other tools in the system: program learning-outcome assessment with rubrics, advisory board skill reviews, course-shell standards, and the evidence cycle for NWCCU and ABET.
Common mistake: P.2c says, “STC is committed to continuous improvement and uses data to drive decisions.”
That’s a sentence, not a system. Name the cycles, their timing, the tools, and how findings move between levels. If course-level learning never reaches program review, and program review never reaches the budget, you have three separate activities, not a system.
Key Takeaway
P.2 covers your competitive position and the changes affecting it, your comparative data sources and their limits, your strategic challenges and advantages, and your performance improvement system. Later categories are checked against it: strategy must address the challenges, and results must be compared using the sources you named. A real improvement system links cycles at different speeds so findings move up and priorities move down.
Add a second page to last lesson’s P.1 draft:
- Three competitor types and how you differ from each
- Three changes affecting your competitive situation
- A comparative-data table: at least four sources and the limitation of each
- Three to five strategic challenges and two or three strategic advantages
- A sketch of your improvement cycles: what runs quarterly, annually, and every few years, and how findings move between them
Share both pages with two colleagues and ask: What did we get wrong or leave out?
1. Which of these belongs in P.2b, Strategic Context?
Strategic challenges, threats, advantages, and opportunities belong in P.2b. Programs, workforce, and suppliers are part of P.1.
2. What's a key limitation of IPEDS as a comparative data source for STC?
IPEDS is federal and free, but it reports for the whole institution and is one to two years old.
3. Why do the strategic challenges listed in P.2b matter later in the assessment?
Category 2 asks whether strategy addresses your challenges and uses your advantages. A challenge with no matching objective is a gap.
4. What turns improvement activities into a performance improvement system?
A system connects cycles at course, program, and school levels so learning flows up and priorities flow down.