Leadership and Governance (Category 1)
How a dean and leadership team set direction, communicate with full-time and adjunct faculty, staff, and students, create an environment for success, and stay accountable through governance, legal and ethical compliance (including AI and academic integrity), and contributions to the community.
What Category 1 Asks
Category 1 (115 points) has two items:
- 1.1 Senior Leadership (65): how senior leaders set and deploy vision and values, promote legal and ethical behavior, communicate and engage people, and create an environment where the mission succeeds with a focus on action.
- 1.2 Governance and Societal Contributions (50): how you make governance accountable, evaluate leaders and the governance system, meet legal, regulatory, and accreditation requirements, behave ethically, and contribute to society.
For a school, the “senior leaders” are usually the dean and the school’s leadership team: associate dean, program directors, and the director of operations or student success. The questions don’t change because you’re one school inside a larger university. You describe your leadership system and how it connects to the university’s.
STC’s Leadership System
A leadership system is the set of things leaders do repeatedly, in a known order, to set direction and keep the school moving. STC’s runs on an annual cycle with monthly and quarterly touchpoints:
| Step | What STC’s leaders actually do |
|---|---|
| 1 Set direction | Each summer the leadership team, with the faculty council, reviews mission, vision, and values against the Organizational Profile and sets the year’s priorities. |
| 2 Communicate | Monthly all-faculty meeting (recorded for adjuncts), a quarterly “dean’s open hour” for students, a weekly adjunct newsletter, and listening channels: anonymous pulse surveys and a program-director check-in with every new adjunct. |
| 3 Build the environment | Protected time for course redesign, a small innovation fund for teaching pilots, and an explicit statement that a failed, well-run pilot isn’t a career risk. |
| 4 Focus on action | Five strategic objectives, each with an owner and quarterly targets (Lesson 3.2), reviewed monthly by the leadership team. |
| 5 Review and learn | An annual 360-degree review of the dean, a yearly faculty-council review of the leadership system, and changes based on what’s learned. |
Notice step 2. Baldrige asks for two-way communication and for engaging all workforce segments. At STC, adjuncts teach most sections, so a leadership system that only reaches full-time faculty misses most of the people who face students.
Governance at the School Level
1.2a asks how your governance system ensures accountability for leaders’ actions, fiscal accountability, transparency, independent audits, and protection of stakeholder interests. It also asks how you evaluate senior leaders and the governance system.
At STC, the board of trustees governs the university, and the school’s governance sits within that. Describe how it works:
- Who holds the dean accountable, and how: the Provost, through an annual review against school objectives
- Shared governance: what the faculty council decides (curriculum, academic standards) and what it advises on (budget, hiring)
- Advisory, not governance: the industry advisory board advises; it has no decision rights, and that should be clear
- Fiscal accountability: monthly budget review with the university’s finance office
Drawn as a structure, the lines of decision and advice look like this:
Legal, Regulatory, Accreditation, and Ethical Behavior
STC keeps a compliance calendar tied to its P.1 regulatory table: NWCCU reporting dates, ABET evidence collection, Title IV and state authorization checks, accessibility audits of course shells, and FERPA training for every new instructor.
1.2b also asks how you anticipate public concerns and how you promote and monitor ethical behavior. In a computing school in 2026, two issues stand out:
- AI and academic integrity. STC publishes a school-wide AI-use framework. Each syllabus states what level of AI use is allowed for each assignment, and faculty get training on designing assessments that hold up.
- Student data and learning analytics. Early-alert tools use LMS data. STC states what’s collected, who sees it, and how it’s used, and a data-governance group reviews new tools before adoption.
Measures STC tracks for this item (reported in 7.4): accreditation and audit findings, accessibility-audit pass rate for course shells, FERPA-training completion, and the number and outcome of academic-integrity cases.
Societal Contributions
1.2c asks how you consider societal well-being in strategy and daily operations, and how you support your key communities. For STC:
- A community cyber clinic where students run free security checkups for local nonprofits, supervised by faculty
- Pathway partnerships with community colleges and high schools to widen access to tech careers
- Workforce diversity goals for the regional tech pipeline, tracked by program
- Environmental impact: auto-shutdown of idle cloud lab resources, which cuts both cost and energy use
Common mistake: STC’s leaders point to a monthly newsletter, a town hall, and an all-faculty email as their “communication and engagement” approach.
Those are all one-way. Baldrige asks how leaders engage the workforce and students, which means listening and responding. Ask: What did leaders learn from faculty, staff, and students this year, and what did they change because of it? If you can’t name an example, especially one that came from adjuncts or online students, the approach isn’t really two-way.
Key Takeaway
Category 1 asks how senior leaders set direction, communicate two-way, build an environment for success, and focus on action, and how governance keeps leaders accountable. For a school inside a university, describe your leadership system and how it connects to the university. Cover legal, regulatory, and accreditation compliance, ethics (including AI use and student data), and societal contributions. Make sure the system reaches the people who teach most of your sections.
Draw your school’s leadership system as a cycle like the one above. For each step, write:
- What leaders do, and how often
- Who it reaches: full-time faculty, adjuncts, staff, students, employers
- One piece of evidence that it works
Then circle any step that doesn’t reach adjuncts or online students. That’s your first Category 1 improvement.
1. For a school within a university, who are the 'senior leaders' in Category 1?
When the school is the unit being assessed, its senior leaders are the dean and leadership team, and you describe how their system connects to the university's.
2. Which approach best shows two-way communication and engagement?
Engagement requires listening and acting on what's heard. Broadcast channels are one-way.
3. Where does STC's school-wide AI-use and academic-integrity framework best fit?
1.2 covers legal, regulatory, and accreditation compliance and how you promote and monitor ethical behavior, which includes integrity and responsible AI use.
4. How should the industry advisory board appear in STC's governance description?
Being clear about who decides and who advises is part of describing an accountable governance system.