Misalignment and Soft Foot
Understand offset and angular misalignment in both vertical and horizontal planes, why misalignment destroys bearings and seals, and how to find and correct soft foot before any alignment.
Why Alignment Pays
Misalignment is one of the leading causes of rotating equipment failure. When two coupled shafts don’t share a common centerline, every revolution flexes the coupling and loads the bearings and seals with extra forces. Results include:
- Shorter bearing life (remember: life drops with the cube of load)
- Seal leaks on pumps and gearboxes
- Coupling wear, heat, and failure
- Higher vibration and noise
- Wasted energy
- Cracked shafts from cyclic bending
The Two Kinds of Misalignment
- Offset (parallel) misalignment: centerlines are parallel but displaced. Measured in thousandths of an inch (mils) or millimeters.
- Angular misalignment: centerlines meet at an angle. Usually expressed as a slope, such as mils per inch (or mm per 100 mm).
Real machines almost always have both, and in both planes:
- Vertical plane: corrected by adding or removing shims under the feet
- Horizontal plane: corrected by moving the machine sideways
So an alignment job corrects four values: vertical offset, vertical angle, horizontal offset, and horizontal angle.
Which Machine Moves?
One machine is the stationary reference (often the pump or gearbox, which is piped or fixed). The other is the movable machine, usually the motor.
Soft Foot: Fix It First
Soft foot is when one or more machine feet don’t sit flat on the base. Tightening the hold-down bolt distorts the machine frame, which can bend the shaft, pinch bearings, and make alignment readings jump around every time you loosen a bolt.
Checking for Soft Foot
- With all feet bolted down, set a dial indicator (or use the laser system’s soft-foot function) at one foot.
- Loosen that one bolt and watch how far the foot rises.
- Retighten, and repeat at each foot.
- A common acceptance limit is about 0.002 inch (2 mils) of movement.
Types of Soft Foot
| Type | What’s happening | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Parallel (short leg) | Foot is simply too low | Add shims under that foot |
| Angular / bent foot | Foot or base is at an angle | Step shims, machine the foot, or correct the base |
| Induced | Pipe strain or a bent frame pulls the machine | Fix the pipe supports or the frame |
| Squishy | Too many shims, dirt, rust, or paint under the foot | Clean, and replace stacks with fewer, thicker shims |
- 1 Lock out
Both machines
- 2 Clean
Feet, base, old shims
- 3 Pipe strain
Unbolt flanges; does it move?
- 4 Soft foot
Under ~2 mils at each foot
- 5 Run-out
Check bent shafts or hubs
- 6 Rough align
Straightedge, then precision
Common mistake: finding eight rusty, mismatched shims under one foot and adding a ninth.
Thick stacks of thin shims act like a spring, so readings won’t repeat and soft foot returns. Pull the old stack, clean the base, and replace with as few shims as possible (a common guide is no more than three or four per foot), using clean pre-cut stainless shims.
Pipe Strain
Pipe that doesn’t line up with a pump’s flanges can be forced into place, pulling the pump out of position. Check by monitoring the coupling with indicators while loosening the flange bolts. If the shaft moves more than a couple of mils, fix the piping supports, not the alignment.
Key Takeaway
Misalignment is offset and angular, in both vertical (shims) and horizontal (move sideways) planes. Before aligning, clean, check pipe strain, and fix soft foot to about 2 mils or less. Use few, clean shims.
You check a motor’s four feet by loosening one bolt at a time and measure lift of:
- Front left: 1 mil
- Front right: 6 mils
- Rear left: 1 mil
- Rear right: 2 mils
Which foot needs attention? (Front right at 6 mils is well over the ~2 mil guideline.) Next, use feeler gauges at the corners of that foot to tell if it’s parallel (same gap all around, so add shims) or angular (wedge-shaped gap, so a step shim or a base correction is needed).
1. Misalignment in the vertical plane is usually corrected by:
Shims raise or lower the feet, adjusting vertical offset and angle.
2. What is soft foot?
Soft foot distorts the frame and bearings when bolts are tightened, and must be corrected before alignment.
3. A common acceptance limit for soft foot is about:
Around 2 mils of movement at a foot is a widely used limit.
4. When loosening a pump's flange bolts, the shaft moves 10 mils. What should you do?
That movement shows pipe strain pulling the pump. Fix the piping before aligning.